Governor wrote: Fri Mar 21, 2025 8:40 am
It is not so simple for me to change OS. It took me two years to get to this point with first fossapup and now bookworm, and I do not relish the though of starting over again with a yet another OS. Also, my portable apps would likely be null and void.
A few things about puppy have been pointed out in the past, but they should re-iterated based on what you've said above:
1) puppy is a semi-fixed-in-time OS structure, meaning it's got an end-of-life cycle based on the up-stream package repos from which it's built, meaning at some point, starting over with a newer puppy is a given.
2) once a working boot loader is installed on your machine, adding addtional forum distros is a simple as copying the files to the drive and adding an appropriate boot stanza to launch it.
3) when a newer puppy is produced to replace one going out of date, a newer one may be built from an entirely different upstream repository, and therefore, is a completely different and brand new OS, though retaining basic puppy frugal installation and filesystems.
4) any user who adopts puppy as a daily driver at some point will have to choose to use outdated software when the upstream repository reaches end-of-life, or upgrade to a more recent puppy, i.e. a brand new and different puppy OS.
Based on these realities, users should think carefully about whether a puppy should be adopted as their daily driver. I like puppies a lot, and booted and worked from Bookworm yesterday, but I don't soley rely on them. I rely on Kennel Linux Void mainly because I prefer Void's rolling release model, in which my KLV OS's are frequently upgraded, including all the standard applications, both command line and gui, things like Geany, or LibreOffice. There are however older pieces of software that the newer Void system will not run, Bookworm still runs them, so I have the best of both worlds. You can do that with these frugally installed forum OS's.
So in a nutshell, the more forum OS's you install, the easier and quicker it becomes to adopt new ones, try them, test them, and even blow them off and go back to the one's you like best.
I personally have toyed with the idea of suggesting a forum topic in the GETTING STARTED section, something like "Should I Use Puppy-LInux?" in which some of these aspects of puppy are discussed, and maybe the type of approach a user who is considering puppy as a daily work horse should be ready to embrace.