Persistently Strange Behavior.... (Open location after running Pfind) [SOLVED]

[Subito Piano]

This I've noticed consistently through many, many iterations of Puppy. I search for a file using Pfind ((MENU>FILESYSTEM>PFIND FILE FINDER), see the file I want, right-click on it, choose "SHOW LOCATION," and receive the error message, "This operation requires single selection. Please select ONE file." I close the error message popup, right-click the file again, again choosing "SHOW LOCATION," and rox-filer opens the location without issue.

This has been going on literally for years, every time i search for a file -- eh, it's one of those things I live with, but it kinda nags at me: what's the issue here??? (IDK if Pfind behaves this way in Slacko.)

Has anyone else expereinced this issue?

[MochiMoppel]

Has anyone else expereinced this issue?

Yes.

You get this error message because nothing is selected at this point. So the message should read "Please select a file". When the message closes you will observe that the right-clicked file is now selected, thus a new attempt to execute a right-click command will succeed. [Edit] ...will succeed only if you right-click the same file. If you right-click other files you will avoid the error message but the command will always act on the previously selected file, not the file you curently right-clicked
This bug affects all commands, not just "Show location". It gets worse when you select on one of commands in the upper menu section, e.g. "Move" or "Open as text". Pfind will assume that all files are selected ... with potentially nasty consequenses.

You can avoid all this by first left-clicking on the file(s) to select them, then use the right-click commands.

[rockedge]

@Subito Piano Yes I see this behavior. It is I believe caused by the fact nothing is really selected directly after the search is finished and shows the results.

So the search finishes, and the files found are displayed and one takes the mouse cursor and goes to a file and right-clicks the mouse and the menu appears. Here one clicks "Show Target" and the error message appears!! This happens because the file is not really selected yet. To prevent the error message go to a file in the search results, then left-click to first select that file and now right-click and "Show Target" works as expected.

In summary, no file is actually selected from the output list so any action from the right-click menu will send that warning to select One file at least.

Screenshot(3).jpg (36.57 KiB) Viewed 1020 times

That is why after the error the second round and beyond will work with the right-click menu.

[MochiMoppel]

after the error the second round and beyond will work with the right-click menu.

Unfortunately not

[bigpup]

I too have seen this error pop up for years using Pfind.

Left click to highlight a listed item.

Then right click on it to get choices.

Seems to work best.

I have noticed if you delay a few seconds, before choosing from the right click menu.
Seems to work more trouble free.

[bigpup]

This is the code in /usr/local/pfind (line 698)

Code: Select all

-show_location)
	if [ `echo "$TREE" | wc -l` != 1 ] || [ ! "$TREE" ]; then #not single selection
		TXT1="<b>$(gettext 'This operation requires single selection. Please select ONE file.')</b>"
		. $PROGPATH/box_ok
		exit 0

Anyone see anything wrong with the code??

[Subito Piano]

OK -- never thought of that, I'm used to being able to simply right click to execute options on a particular file (e.g., in rox-filer, right clicking automatically selects the file, then one picks to "open as text" or "copy" or whatever. Thanks, all --

@bigpup Agreed..."the things nobody tells us..." It took ten years before I found out why my word processor would suddenly overwrite the existing text instead of inserting it! (solution: toggling the "insert" key)

[Burunduk]

I have Pfind 6.3 on Fossapup64-9.5. There is a clear intention to do something in this situation in /usr/local/pfind/func line 115:

Code: Select all

-rightclick_menu)
	#external menu
	if [ $BUTTON = 3 ]; then
		echo -n > /tmp/pfind-tmp$PROGPID
		if [ `echo "$TREE" | wc -l` != 1 ] || [ ! "$TREE" ]; then SENSITIVE='<sensitive>false</sensitive>'; fi #not single selection

As you can see, the variable SENSITIVE is set when no or many items are selected. It should make the right-click menu inactive but the variable is never used. Maybe using it could have some unwanted side effects, I don't know. On Fossa, inserting the sensitive directive seems to work correctly - menu is only usable if exactly one item is selected. Insert '$SENSITIVE' right before </window> (line 136):

Code: Select all

		 <action signal="focus-out-event">EXIT:exit</action>
		 '$SENSITIVE'
		</window>'

I think it would be better to show no menu at all because it cannot be used anyway. With the following modification, a right-click shows the context menu if one item is selected and selects an item (as a left-click does) otherwise - just replace SENSITIVE='<sensitive>false</sensitive>' with exit on line 115:

Code: Select all

-rightclick_menu)
	#external menu
	if [ $BUTTON = 3 ]; then
		echo -n > /tmp/pfind-tmp$PROGPID
		if [ `echo "$TREE" | wc -l` != 1 ] || [ ! "$TREE" ]; then exit; fi #not single selection

Alternatively, this only hides the right-click menu when no item is selected. For multiple selection the menu works:

Code: Select all

-rightclick_menu)
	#external menu
	if [ $BUTTON = 3 ]; then
		echo -n > /tmp/pfind-tmp$PROGPID
		if [ ! "$TREE" ]; then exit; fi #no selection

But it's still confusing though: the right-click menu operates on the previously selected row and not on the one under the mouse pointer.

[MochiMoppel]

Code: Select all

-show_location)
	if [ `echo "$TREE" | wc -l` != 1 ] || [ ! "$TREE" ]; then #not single selection
		TXT1="<b>$(gettext 'This operation requires single selection. Please select ONE file.')</b>"
		. $PROGPATH/box_ok
		exit 0

Anyone see anything wrong with the code??

Nothing wrong with this code. Works perfectly.

But it's still confusing though: the right-click menu operates on the previously selected row and not on the one under the mouse pointer.

This is what I meant when I used the "b" word. This is the real bug here, the rest are mere annoyances.
It should be fixed and I'm sure it can be fixed, but this has to happen in the pfind main script. The "button-press-event" code in the <tree> widget looks wrong.

In line 282 of /usr/local/pfind/pfind change
<action signal="button-press-event">. '$PROGPATH'/func -rightclick_menu</action>
to
<action signal="button-release-event">. '$PROGPATH'/func -rightclick_menu</action>

[Burunduk]

In line 282 of /usr/local/pfind/pfind change
<action signal="button-press-event">. '$PROGPATH'/func -rightclick_menu</action>
to
<action signal="button-release-event">. '$PROGPATH'/func -rightclick_menu</action>

Congratulations, you've fixed this! A small tip: to preserve the multiple selection keep holding ctrl or shift key until the right-click.
Now I can forget about Pfind again, never used it - it's too complicated for me.

[Subito Piano]

@MochiMoppel Wow! That is so cool! Kudos, you've got mad skills.

[MochiMoppel]

@Subito Piano I guess "mad" nails it. Poking around in funny code of an application that I don't even use

Doing so I found another configuration mistake. When clicking on "Show location" Pfind was originally designed to open a ROX-Filer window and jump to the selected file. It doesn't do this anymore. Instead it will only open the directory where the file resides and then you will have to find the file by eyeballing through a potentially long list of files.

Here is how you can get the original behavior back:
In the upper menu of Pfind go to File => Configure => "Settings" tab => Default File manager. Here change defaultfilemanager to rox., then press "OK". That's it.

Some technical background:
Originally Pfind was created with "rox" as the only file manager, allowing the rox -s command to jump to a file. 12 years ago, when users demanded support for other file managers, zigbert added this code to the -show_location function:

Code: Select all

if [ $FILEMANAGER = rox ]; then
	exec rox -s "$TREE" 2> /tmp/pfind-error$PROGPID
else
	exec $FILEMANAGER "${TREE%/*}/" 2> /tmp/pfind-error$PROGPID
fi

The FILEMANAGER variable is set in the file /usr/local/pfind/pfindrc, and originally it was set to "rox". So far, so good.
However some time after that it was changed to "defaultfilemanager", which may sound like a good idea, but someone understanding above code will realize that now rox -s will never be executed, even if defaultfilemanager is scripted to execute rox. I noticed this setting in @radky 's BM64 and @rockedge 's FP96.
IMO should be changed back, probably in woof-CE.

[Burunduk]

Poking around in funny code of an application that I don't even use

As I've said before, neither do I. But what about the rox-filer itself? It's my favorite file manager and it worked well until this forum thread. Now I've opened it, selected a file, right-clicked another one, and - déjà vu! - got the context menu for the first. You understand the gtk mechanics far better than me. Do you have any thoughts how to solve this problem too?
Or is it a problem at all if it remained unnoticed for such a long time? Nonetheless, it would be nice to make it work as Xfe does - change a single selection but preserve the multiple one on a displaced right-click.

[MochiMoppel]

But what about the rox-filer itself? It's my favorite file manager and it worked well until this forum thread. Now I've opened it, selected a file, right-clicked another one, and - déjà vu! - got the context menu for the first. You understand the gtk mechanics far better than me. Do you have any thoughts how to solve this problem too?
Or is it a problem at all if it remained unnoticed for such a long time?

Sorry for the very late reply. I didn't quite understand what you mean, and as the problem was declared "solved" and everybody seemed to be happy, I didn't check further.

But now I have second thoughts. Yes, that's how ROX-Filer works, and no, I don't think it's a problem. I rather think that the behavior of pFind before the "bugfix" was better. The rule is: Make selection first, then right click for the context menu. Always 2 steps. Do not try to make a selection with right click.

With the new "bugfix" it becomes difficult to right click a selection of multiple files.
I've now ran into the same problem with one of my own applications and I therefore implemented the behavior of ROX. I agree that the solution of Xfe is much more intuitive. Unfortunately it's impossible to achieve with gtkdialog.

[Subito Piano]

Sounds like users now have a choice which way they would like Pfind to work. Freedom and (relative) ease to modify...isn't that one of the main reasons ppl. choose Linux, and particularly Puppy?