What issues with NoblePup need to be resolved?

[Marv]

Signed in to GitHub but the test build link still gives me a 404. Still building?

[peebee]

Signed in to GitHub but the test build link still gives me a 404. Still building?

Try: https://github.com/peabee/woof-CE/relea ... 24.08-test

[Marv]

It's there, thanks, but I'm getting network errors on my end & it won't resume. I'll do a reconnect and try again later or in the morning.

Got it. MPV play checked in a pristine boot. Normal quicksetup only done. DVDs play correctly using MPV now. Video and audio fine, fullscreen mode and switch back fine, controls seem fully functional. I did have to add libdvdcss libraries for my 'problem' ones to play. I used the libdvdcss2_1.4.3-dmo2_amd64.deb I used to add them to my adrive.

Very quick check in my LXDE'd install. Basically runs but due to the different naming convention in the test iso, the install wasn't ideal.

Thanks,

[Jasper]

Uploaded the 05 September 2024 ISO & additional files to Mediafire:

https://forum.puppylinux.com/viewtopic. ... 05#p130405

[LateAdopter]

Try: https://github.com/peabee/woof-CE/relea ... 24.08-test

I've downloaded and installed this one and done all my usual tweaks up to loading my Vivaldi SFS so I can post from it now.
It's working fine but, as usual, I have to switch to the intel driver as the modesetting driver is always berserk on this Braswell N3150 CPU.

Two minor issues: The Connman taskbar icon is invisible. The gatotray.bin64 symlink is missing from /root/startup and .../disabled so the setting gui gives an error.

Thank you for this.

[Jasper]

@peebee

Is the 05 Sept ISO based on Ubuntu 24.04.1 (Noble Numbat) ?

[peebee]

@peebee

Is the 05 Sept ISO based on Ubuntu 24.04.1 (Noble Numbat) ?

I would imagine so - it uses whatever Noble components were available on 5 September........ you can check in /var/packages

[Jasper]

@peebee

Thanks for letting me know

Just a 'heads up', my previous 'save' file did not work with this build.

Previous build

puppy_upup64n_24.04.sfs

new build

puppy_noblepup64_24.08.sfs

hahahhaa .............. forgot to say 'so far, so good' ..... did not use the firmware sfs. All applications appear to start up as expected.

.......... have not used Synaptic Package Manager.

btop.png (98.2 KiB) Viewed 948 times

[LateAdopter]

I have just checked whether va-api was working. It's mostly installed but the package i965-va-driver is not installed but it is needed for my Braswell n3150 when using the intel driver instead of modesetting. It would also be needed for older graphics cards that predate crocus.

I have installed the package and va-api is now working.

[dimkr]

It looks like noble64 doesn't have va-driver-all preinstalled (unlike most dpup configurations), kernel modules are xz-compressed (because CONFIG_MODULE_COMPRESS_XZ is =y in Ubuntu) so module loading at boot time is CPU intensive and slower ... there are many things that can be optimized. Maybe it would be easier to start from scratch, with the BookwormPup64 configuration as the starting point.

[peebee]

It looks like noble64 doesn't have va-driver-all preinstalled (unlike most dpup configurations), kernel modules are xz-compressed (because CONFIG_MODULE_COMPRESS_XZ is =y in Ubuntu) so module loading at boot time is CPU intensive and slower ... there are many things that can be optimized. Maybe it would be easier to start from scratch, with the BookwormPup64 configuration as the starting point.

Thats because it had been disabled (see no.txt above):
no|libva|libva2,libva-drm2,libva-x11-2,vainfo,va-driver-all|exe,dev,doc,nls||deps:yes #needed by mplayer.

What should it have?
yes|libva|vainfo,va-driver-all|exe,dev,doc,nls||deps:yes
which expands with dependencies to:
yes|libva|vainfo,va-driver-all,libva-drm2,libva-x11-2,libva2,i965-va-driver,intel-media-va-driver,mesa-va-drivers,libigdgmm12|exe,dev,doc,nls||deps:yes

[dimkr]

What should it have?

That depends on your goals I guess. If you want minimum size, I guess you want VA-API drivers out. If you want lower CPU usage, better battery life and better browser performance, the other way around.

[Jasper]

@peebee

Would it be possible in a future update to include PupMTP (libmtp) which allows MTP devices to be recognised and connected?

In the interim if anyone needs to connect a device eg Android phone then this SFS will work:

https://forum.puppylinux.com/viewtopic. ... 56#p126856

[peebee]

@Jasper

I did not intend to become the maintainer of NoblePup64!!
I have recently done a bit of "tidying up" after interest was expressed in the existing periodic build of NoblePup64.
I would prefer it if somebody else could now undertake future maintenance and improvement.
You just have to fork Woof-CE - make changes in your fork including test builds - then push the changes back into Woof-CE for the periodic builds.
I will help if you get into problems.

Any takers?

[Jasper]

@peebee

Apologies, but thank you for the work so far.

The next point release is not due till next year, so this offering is good as it it is

I am not familiar with the actions/use of GitHub, but am willing to participate.

I will need a lot of 'holding hands' at the start until I get up to speed.

Anyone else willing to take this up as well?

[peebee]

no.txt shows:

no|simple-mtpfs||exe,dev,doc,nls #pupmtp
no|libmtp||exe,dev,doc,nls #pupmtp

these are pets in common64

I will add these and:
yes|libva|vainfo,va-driver-all|exe,dev,doc,nls||deps:yes

as my last "tidy-up"

[peebee]

https://github.com/peabee/woof-CE/relea ... .04-240907

release-action.png (167.14 KiB) Viewed 806 times

[Jasper]

@peebee

Much appreciated .......... have a great weekend!!!

[dimkr]

I am not familiar with the actions/use of GitHub, but am willing to participate.

https://github.com/puppylinux-woof-CE/w ... ibutor-101
https://github.com/puppylinux-woof-CE/w ... -on-GitHub

(However, understanding basic git concepts like branches and commits will help a lot; GitHub itself has good git tutorials and I can recommend them if you want to understand what you're doing)

[Marv]

Updated my 240902 install on the Fujitsu S761, frugal Grub4Dos to SSD to the 240907 build. No issues noted. Dmesg clean, lidsuspend works ,DVD plays correctly from event handler, all portables continue to function well, printing to Brother 2170 laserprinter fine, haven't checked much else yet but but all seems good here so far.

Indeed Jasper, the connman tray icon could use a bit of work. If I could find the goldarn thing I'd recolor it.

Thanks peebee for the bonus cleanup

[peebee]

the connman tray icon could use a bit of work. If I could find the goldarn thing I'd recolor it.

Maybe:
/usr/share/icons/Adwaita/symbolic/status/network-offline-symbolic.svg

icon.png (18.31 KiB) Viewed 680 times

[peebee]

Radky suggests

Code: Select all

cp -f usr/share/connman_ui_gtk/icons/*.svg usr/share/icons/Adwaita/symbolic/status

in
https://github.com/puppylinux-woof-CE/w ... .conf#L146

i.e. overwrite the Adwaita icons

[Joshua26]

It looks like noble64 doesn't have va-driver-all preinstalled (unlike most dpup configurations), kernel modules are xz-compressed (because CONFIG_MODULE_COMPRESS_XZ is =y in Ubuntu) so module loading at boot time is CPU intensive and slower ... there are many things that can be optimized. Maybe it would be easier to start from scratch, with the BookwormPup64 configuration as the starting point.

It is clear that noble64's absence of preloaded 'va-driver-all' and use of xz-compressed kernel modules may result in slower boot times. Starting from scratch with the BookwormPup64 setup may result in a more optimized and efficient system.

[dimkr]

Adwaita is no longer a full icon theme (see https://gitlab.gnome.org/GNOME/adwaita- ... issues/288), it's supposed to 1) act as fallback when you use a different theme, through Inherits=Adwaita or 2) be used directly by applications, ignoring the system theme. If you want to replace the symbolic icons, I think it would be best to add Puppy-themed symbolic icons to the Puppy themes instead of modifying Adwaita and possibly causing issues in GTK+ 4 applications that use Adwaita.

In my builds, I dropped the Puppy icon themes because I think it's a waste of time to try to preserve them when GTK+ is doing its thing, especially without a dedicated artwork team that can keep up with the amount of work needed to chase changes in Adwaita.

[Marv]

I have satisfactory (for me) network tray icons. Neither the stock Adwaita ones (the Puppy themes default to those as well) nor those in /usr/share/connman_ui_gtk/icons work well with my panel background.

I edited the icons in /usr/share/connman_ui_gtk/icons using libreoffice draw and put them in my theme, which is a clone of flat-remix so I stay 'additive' and don't goof existing themes up.

I could only get those icons to be picked up by connman from the system icon theme if they were in the symbolic/status directory under the theme name there as they are in Adwaita. I don't know why the Directories line in my theme index didn't take care of that using the flat-remix structure, but it didn't. I think I had it all in correctly,

So, in my theme I use the structure (theme/symbolic/status) rather than the (theme/status/symbolic) structure used in flat-remix. Changes, of course have to be reflected in the index.theme file within the theme. Works correctly wrt. the icons, everything else I've used seems unchanged from the flat-remix I was using previously and used as the base for my clone, and the new theme is carried in my adrive only.

I don't expect anyone else to be nuts enough to pursue this but It is doable and doesn't in any way change the core puppy.