Clarity wrote: Thu Feb 27, 2025 9:46 am
hello Barry. I saw you post of your issue with a new stick.
I offer this: My oldest PC is a 2007 64bit which is the 2nd year of all manufacturers upgrading, as you will remember. ALL of them boot a GPT-based USB/disk without issue. And we know the benefits. Not sure why to insist MSDOS as this may not be the case anymore.
If members have problems, I'm sure they will respond the actual conditions should any arise from any GPT based IMG you share for our use..
This is just a note of my experiences.
https://www.ventoy.net/en/doc_mbr_vs_gpt.html
Does MBR support Legacy BIOS and UEFI ?
Yes. But there are some machines whose UEFI firmware only recognize disk in GPT format, so MBR will NOT be compatible in this case.
Does GPT support Legacy BIOS and UEFI ?
Yes. GPT is part of the UEFI spec, so GPT supports UEFI without any compatibility issues.
But for Legacy BIOS, there may be some compatibility problems with some machine, that's why I give 3 stars here, see Notes
To be exactly, the active flag can't be set in GPT's protect MBR. Besides the partition type (0xEE) is not accepted by some BIOS.